The Tidewater Boats 1900 Bay Max 2009 is a modified-V design and the Tidewater Boats 1996 2012 is a tri-hull design, so you're likely deciding between two noticeably different on-water experiences. Hull type shapes everything from ride quality and fuel burn to dock handling and resale trajectory.
On paper these two are close siblings in the size department - Tidewater Boats 1900 Bay Max 2009 at 19,2 ft versus Tidewater Boats 1996 2012 at 19,0 ft. At 1 600 lbs and 1 500 lbs respectively, both sit in a similar weight class - either should pair comfortably with most mid-size SUVs and half-ton trucks, though always confirm your specific tow rating with the motor added.
The power gap is worth calling out. Rated to 150 hp, the Tidewater Boats 1900 Bay Max 2009 has a 35-hp advantage over the Tidewater Boats 1996 2012's 115-hp ceiling - enough to notice on acceleration and at cruising speed, particularly with a full passenger load. Fuel capacity breaks the other way: the Tidewater Boats 1900 Bay Max 2009 carries 60 gallons versus 30 gallons in the Tidewater Boats 1996 2012. On a lake day that's negligible, but for coastal cruising or long reservoir runs the extra range matters.
Both boats are rated for 5 passengers - a good fit for a family of four or five plus guests. Comfort at capacity is another matter; the longer hull typically means more seat options and better weight distribution.
Bottom line: Performance buyers should lean toward the Tidewater Boats 1900 Bay Max 2009 and its 150-hp ceiling. If fuel economy and quieter running matter more than top-end speed, the Tidewater Boats 1996 2012 with its 115-hp rating is the more economical daily driver.