The Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 is a pontoon design and the Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 is a modified-V design, so you're likely deciding between two noticeably different on-water experiences. Hull type shapes everything from ride quality and fuel burn to dock handling and resale trajectory.
On paper these two are close siblings in the size department - Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 at 18,8 ft versus Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 at 16,0 ft. Weight tells a clearer story for trailering families: the Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 tips the scales at 1 550 lbs - 470 lbs more than the Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 at 1 080 lbs. That difference is meaningful if you're working within a half-ton or three-quarter-ton truck's tow rating, especially once you factor in a motor, gear, and fuel.
The power gap is worth calling out. Rated to 90 hp, the Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 has a 40-hp advantage over the Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012's 50-hp ceiling - enough to notice on acceleration and at cruising speed, particularly with a full passenger load. Both carry nearly identical fuel loads - 24 gal and 24 gal - so range won't be a tiebreaker here.
For family outings this is probably the sharpest distinction between the two. The Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 is rated for 8 passengers, while the Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 caps at 5. If you're regularly pulling extended family or a group of friends onto the water, the extra seats on the Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 could be the deciding factor.
Bottom line: Choose the Sylvan Mirage Fish 818 2012 if your priority is putting more people on the water - it handles 8 passengers and at 18,8 ft it has the deck room to back that rating up comfortably. The Sylvan Pro Sport 1600 DC 2009 is the smarter pick if you want a lighter, easier-to-trailer boat rated for 5 that costs less to run day-to-day.