The Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009 is a modified-V design and the Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 is a pontoon design, so you're likely deciding between two noticeably different on-water experiences. Hull type shapes everything from ride quality and fuel burn to dock handling and resale trajectory.
Size is the most obvious dividing line here. The Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 measures 20,8 feet overall (2012), giving it roughly 4,8 additional feet of deck space compared to the Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009 at 16,0 feet (2009). Weight tells a clearer story for trailering families: the Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 tips the scales at 1 850 lbs - 1 000 lbs less than the Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009 at 850 lbs. That difference is meaningful if you're working within a half-ton or three-quarter-ton truck's tow rating, especially once you factor in a motor, gear, and fuel.
The power gap is worth calling out. Rated to 115 hp, the Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 has a 40-hp advantage over the Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009's 75-hp ceiling - enough to notice on acceleration and at cruising speed, particularly with a full passenger load. Both carry nearly identical fuel loads - 24 gal and 24 gal - so range won't be a tiebreaker here.
For family outings this is probably the sharpest distinction between the two. The Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 is rated for 10 passengers, while the Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009 caps at 5. If you're regularly pulling extended family or a group of friends onto the water, the extra seats on the Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 could be the deciding factor.
Bottom line: Choose the Sylvan Mirage Fish 8520 4-PT 2012 if your priority is putting more people on the water - it handles 10 passengers and at 20,8 ft it has the deck room to back that rating up comfortably. The Sylvan Explorer 1600 SC 2009 is the smarter pick if you want a lighter, easier-to-trailer boat rated for 5 that costs less to run day-to-day.